Collector Finds

Stricter return rules may increase chargebacks

By Bianca Foster November 18, 2026
Stricter return rules may increase chargebacks - return rules
Of that amount, $14 billion stemmed from outright fraud, while $86 billion resulted from policy abuses, including tactics like wardrobing and bracketing.

A payments disputes firm has alerted retailers that implementing stricter return policies may simply transfer financial losses from refunds to chargebacks—a concern gaining attention as stores ready for Black Friday. The company referenced industry data highlighting the scope of this challenge within the US returns sector.

According to Appriss Retail, out of the $706 billion in goods returned last year, $100 billion represented preventable fraud and policy violations, accounting for 14.2% of all returns. Of that amount, $14 billion stemmed from outright fraud, while $86 billion resulted from policy abuses, including tactics like wardrobing and bracketing.

In response, numerous retailers have tightened return processes by introducing fees, shortening return windows, or enforcing stricter proof-of-purchase requirements. However, available data suggests these measures do not consistently curb abusive behavior. The NRF and Happy Returns 2025 Retail Returns Landscape Report revealed that roughly two-thirds of shoppers admitted to engaging in at least one costly return practice.

How Return Policies Influence Customer Actions

Additional research from eMarketer showed that 44% of merchants experienced an increase in fraud after implementing return fees, while 42% observed a decline. Meanwhile, overly restrictive policies risk alienating legitimate buyers. Appriss Retail found that eight out of ten consumers said a smooth returns process would encourage them to shop with a retailer again.

Chargebacks911 contends that the consequences of stricter return rules may not surface immediately at the returns counter but could later appear in dispute resolutions. The firm’s 2026 Chargeback Field Report indicated that 27.1% of merchant returns involved some form of abuse, and 62% of businesses classified refund abuse as a moderate or serious issue.

Rising Chargeback Concerns Among Merchants

The same report disclosed that 61.8% of retailers reported a rise in chargebacks over the past three years, with friendly fraud growing faster than overall dispute volumes. Monica Eaton, CEO of Chargebacks911, noted that the trade-off between fraud prevention, customer satisfaction, and chargeback risks becomes especially pronounced during peak shopping seasons.

“They ease return policies and see abuse spike. They tighten rules and lose customers.

Chargebacks911 points out that many merchants treat returns fraud and chargebacks as distinct problems, even when the same individuals or behavioral patterns appear in both areas. This separation can obscure repeated misuse and missed opportunities for early intervention.

She emphasized that retailers should prioritize distinguishing between normal shopping behavior and patterns consistently driving financial losses.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *